Harmonica positions explained visually

A position is which note you treat as home on a harmonica built around a different one. Each position number moves that home note one fifth further along: second position on a C harmonica plays in G, third in D. The instrument does not change — only which of its notes is the root, and that one decision gives every other note a new job.

A C harmonica with every hole labelled by its scale degree in first position. The roots sit on the blow notes of holes 1, 4, 7 and 10.
First position on a C harmonica. Every note the instrument can produce, labelled with what it does relative to home. The rings mark the root: blow 1, 4, 7 and 10 — the note the harmonica is named after.

How to read one of these maps

The strip on the left names the rows. Blow and Draw are the notes you get with no technique at all; Channel is the hole numbers.

Everything above and below those two rows costs a technique, and the short vertical line between holes 6 and 7 is where the technique changes. Below the draw row and left of that line sit the draw bends, labelled 0.5, 1 and 1.5 by how far the note is bent down; right of it, the same rows hold overdraws. The two unlabelled rows at the top work the same way round: overblows on the left, blow bends on the right.

The labels are not note names but scale degrees: 1 is the home note, 3 a major third above it, b7 a minor seventh, and so on. That is the whole point of reading the harmonica this way. Note names change with every harp you pick up; the degrees do not. Learn where b7 lives in second position and you know it on all twelve keys.

The same C harmonica, every field labelled with its note name instead of its scale degree.
The same instrument, labelled the other way. Note names answer “what am I playing”. Scale degrees answer “what is it doing”. You need both, at different moments.

Working out the key

Positions are counted around the circle of fifths. Each step up adds seven semitones to the home note, so:

All twelve positions on a C harmonica. Positions 1 to 6 and 12 land on the seven modes of the harmonica’s own major scale; 7 to 11 land on roots the instrument does not have as a plain note.
PositionKey on a C harpMode you land inNotes on it
1stCIonian (major)“Straight harp”. Melodies, folk, anything that stays in the major scale
2ndGMixolydian“Cross harp”. Blues, rock, country — the flat seventh is a plain draw note
3rdDDorian“Slant harp”. Minor with a major sixth; the usual home for minor tunes
4thAAeolian (natural minor)The whole scale sits under plain notes in the middle octave
5thEPhrygianDarker minor; the flat second is what you hear
6thBLocrianThe fifth above the root is flattened, so nothing quite settles
7thF#—The root itself is not a plain note. You have to bend or overblow before you can even play home
8thDb—
9thAb—
10thEb—Same, but surprisingly interesting for major
11thBb—Same, but surprisingly interesting for major
12thFLydianThe raised fourth is built in and gives this position its elevated touch

Backwards works the same way. If the band plays in E and you want second position, count one fifth down from E and you arrive at A: you need an A harmonica. Third position in E needs a D harp, fourth needs G, fifth needs C.

Which harmonica for which key

The same sum for all twelve keys at once, so nobody has to count fifths on stage.

Which harmonica plays which key, in every position. Find the key of the song in the left column and read across to the position you want. It works the other way round too: find your harmonica inside a column, and the row it sits in is the key it plays there.
Song key1st2nd3rd4th5th6th7th8th9th10th11th12th
CCFBbEbAbDbF#BEADG
DbDbF#BEADGCFBbEbAb
DDGCFBbEbAbDbF#BEA
EbEbAbDbF#BEADGCFBb
EEADGCFBbEbAbDbF#B
FFBbEbAbDbF#BEADGC
F#F#BEADGCFBbEbAbDb
GGCFBbEbAbDbF#BEAD
AbAbDbF#BEADGCFBbEb
AADGCFBbEbAbDbF#BE
BbBbEbAbDbF#BEADGCF
BBEADGCFBbEbAbDbF#

Which position you want is decided by the tune, not by the key. Major and blues: second. A minor tune with a bright sixth: third. A straight melody: first. Everything past sixth position needs a bend or an overblow just to reach the root — worth knowing it is there, not worth starting there.

Sharp keys are written with flats here, the way harmonicas are sold: a song in C# needs the harp with Db stamped on it.

What changes between positions

Compare first and second position on the same instrument. The notes are identical. What moves is where the important ones land, and how much work each one costs.

The same C harmonica labelled for second position. The roots now sit on draw 2, blow 3, blow 6 and blow 9, and the flat seventh appears on draw 5 and draw 9.
Second position on the same C harmonica. The roots moved to draw 2, blow 3, blow 6 and blow 9 — and a b7 appeared on draw 5 and draw 9, where first position had a plain fourth.

That flat seventh is most of the story. Blues, rock and a lot of country lean on the dominant seventh chord, and in second position the harmonica simply hands it to you on a draw note. In first position you would have to bend for it. The instrument is not more “bluesy” in second position; the notes a blues wants are just easier to reach.

Third position moves the home note one fifth further and lands somewhere quite different:

The same C harmonica labelled for third position with minor scale degrees. The roots sit on draw 1, draw 4 and draw 8.
Third position, read as a minor scale. The roots are on draw 1, draw 4 and draw 8. The minor third and the flat seventh are both plain notes, which is why third position is the usual home for minor tunes.

The three octaves are not the same instrument

This took me longest to get, and it has nothing to do with which position you are in. It is simply how Richter tuning is built.

So “the same scale degree in the octave above” can mean a plain draw note in one place and a blow bend in another. Seeing all the octaves at once is the fastest way to stop being surprised by that.

Practice: find one function everywhere

  1. Take any harmonica and decide on second position. Play the root in every octave you can reach: draw 2, blow 3, blow 6, blow 9. Listen for the moment the timbre changes as you cross into the top octave.
  2. Now do the same with the flat seventh: draw 5, draw 9, and the whole-step bend of draw 2. The same job three times, and three completely different things to do with your mouth.
  3. Repeat with the major third: draw 3, draw 7, and the blow bend on hole 10. This one is worth the trouble, because the third is what tells a listener whether you are in major or minor.
  4. Only then play a scale. It will feel different, because you now know what each note is for.

A common misconception

“Second position is the blues position and third position is the minor position.” That is a good rule of thumb and a poor rule. Position numbers do not carry a mood. (Even if they move the sound in that direction.) What they carry is a particular arrangement of easy notes and hard notes, and different music finds different arrangements convenient. Plenty of great blues is played in first, third and twelfth position; plenty of minor tunes work in fourth or fifth. If you choose a position by the label rather than by which notes you actually need, you will sometimes make the tune harder than it has to be.

The useful question is not “which position is this style in” but “which notes does this tune lean on, and where do they fall”.

The same map for your own harmonica

Everything above is one harmonica in three positions.